Ihearthockey

10 minutes ago, Stackthepads said:

Nobody tried to deceive anyone…everybody knew where the player was from the entire season, the situation was disclosed and the roster was approved. There was never any “cover-up”.  If it’s the rule, fine, but don’t say that adults were trying to pull a fast one.  EVERYONE KNEW AND WAITED UNTIL THE SEASON WAS OVER TO COMPLAIN - FACT!  And yes, the highest scoring offense in the division is being held out of the playoffs.

Montour is most likely in AA if everything was done correctly.  The season plays out much differently.  JMO.

Wow, color me a little surprised.  

I guess it makes sense now all the garbage posts have pretty much stopped.  

1 hour ago, hockey57410 said:

A go fund me? Who’s donating to that?

He had his phone number in the post.  Looks like it was removed.  

The boards are ripe with guilt today

1 minute ago, Jkersman01 said:

This! Smells fishy. Be careful here. Hopefully this gets removed. 

Yeah, I'm with you here.  Somebody knows somebody's phone number.  This kid may get calls and he'll have no idea why.  

Hoping it gets removed too.

19 minutes ago, AvonworthFan123 said:

100% agreed man. If you have any questions call let me know and call me.  I am officially starting my campaign for PIHL president. Someone get the GoFundMe started. I am so f***ing ready, baby!!!

I recommend removing this post.  But that's just me.  

To keep it from getting buried....

The student is a billeted player, unless a court-appointed guardianship is in place between the player and the hostfamily. This does not pertain to foreign students who have been approved by USA Hockey

Is the student a billet, living with somebody other than his parents out of state for the purposes of playing hockey? YES/NO

Did the student's parents sign over guardianship to the billet family? YES/NO

Did Montour submit the paperwork to have this student treated as an exception to the Athletic Intent rule? YES/NO

Did PIHL approve the exception paperwork? YES/NO

Seems pretty straightforward to me.  

1 minute ago, Overqualified said:

40 years of coaching and playing professionally 

Winner Winner chicken diner

You missed another opportunity to misplace an apostrophe

1 hour ago, Pucks11 said:

Everyone just stop replying to "Yalldumb" it is clearly a young kid that lacks the basic skills of understanding what's right and what's wrong. He will continue to repeat himself even when people give him the perfect answer to his questions but because he doesn't understand or doesn't WANT to understand he just keeps arguing the same thing over and over again.

Add "Overqualified" to this list.  And all the other newcomers.

Just now, Danner27 said:

Correct, This is my feeling too. 

Sets a great precedence.  Cheat, lawyer up, brush it under the rug, repeat.  

3 minutes ago, Overqualified said:

And your a rocket scientist 

Are you talking to yourself?

Whatever the outcome is, it should be public soon.  "A" play in games start 2/27.

19 minutes ago, Theroadtobeerleague said:

Wait a second…

the other goalie…

.836 save percentage 

gave up 4 goals each time he started vs Wheeling Park (who won zero total games)

played the majority of his games vs the bottom teams   Lost to QV 4-1 in his only start vs a team that made the playoffs   
 

so, um, not really “pretty solid”

 

 

Well, I guess we will never know

1 minute ago, Icebucket said:

I agree that the parents anger should be directed towards their own board.  However, I'd think that had they went through the process the player would have been told he had to sit out this year.  And then who knows where the team lands without him.

Ironically I bet they still make the playoffs.  The other goalie was pretty solid in a very competitive division. 

13 hours ago, Danner27 said:

Well, this guy might know a thing or two about what’s going on there. 
 

Go back to this guys tweets in March of 22.  Interesting banter with the Montour board.

Ok.  Just so we don't lose sight of this

The student is a billeted player, unless a court-appointed guardianship is in place between the player and the hostfamily. This does not pertain to foreign students who have been approved by USA Hockey

Can anybody in Montour confirm that this goalie does not fall into this category?

1 minute ago, Hoxkeydad said:

Gets my sympathy for sure.  Knows what they’re  talking about.    Oh…and have a good night. Don’t let it bother you too much it’s just youth hockey  

Running out of ammo aren't ya buddy.  

Rules good.  Cheating bad.  

Hopefully that's simple enough.

Done with you 

8 minutes ago, Hoxkeydad said:

Expand on that.  I’m sure you think they brought  in a ringer,  recruited from out of state and on and on.  Big cheaters they are.  They had a frigging freshman goalie that wanted to have fun playing HS and meet kids that happen to be good and made some people butts hurt.  

No need to.  As I've said previously, if you've done it by the rules good for you. If not reap what you sow.

See, you seem to mistake me for somebody who cares about which school makes it to the playoffs. All I care is that the rules are followed. Now if you guys come out smelling like roses on the other end of this you can come on this website and say told you so but I won't lose a minute of sleep. Because I don't care. All I care about is that the rules are followed and are appropriately applied.

2 minutes ago, Hoxkeydad said:

Umm the comment I replied to said “Montour should probably not be playing A hockey with that kid”.  I think I was on topic.  Stay with us  BTW I got nothing against QV or any HS program.  I’m for letting kids play 

At any expense eh?

5 minutes ago, Hoxkeydad said:

They should not have been allowed to play with a 2007 freshman Esmark AAA kid, but QV can play with an Esmark 2006 AAA sophomore goalie.  Ok that sounds logical.  

Off topic fella.  Start a QV thread if you're all butthurt about them.  

1 minute ago, Mr.lovable said:

From what I’ve heard the kid was 14 when he moved and beating 18 year olds. he was probably taking on a lot of stress and other things at the time. All he wanted to do was play hockey and now there’s a team who’s mad because they didn’t get into playoffs. And which the team is trying to take advantage of the commissioner who died who gave the goalie permission. Sad life to stop a 14 year old kid from playing the sport he loves, Wild.

Dude you can say it over and over and over.  You wont get sympathy on this board except from Hoxkeydad.  It sounds like you broke the rules.  Read the effin rules.  They are in place for a reason.  Done with you.  

4 minutes ago, Mr.lovable said:

Oh boy. Here we go. Another person who has no clue what there talking about....

Lol.  You must be a parent

I was unbiased before but now I want you guys to be disqualified.

2 minutes ago, Mr.lovable said:

What it seems like to me is that the commissioner gave the goalie approval, then which he died and now Avonworth is trying to take advantage of his death and cheat there way into playoffs. ? 

Oh boy.  Here we go.  

 new sign up, 2 posts....stirring the pot. 

3 minutes ago, hockey57410 said:

Guess kid is leaving to go home as soon as aaa season is over too. 

I've heard the same.  

2 hours ago, Danner27 said:

If your guys broke the rules or tried to pull a fast one, I hope you are disqualified from the playoffs. If everything is legit, I hope it’s all tossed out & your kids get to play. 

This.  

The kid went 9-1.  Montour should probably not be playing A hockey with that kid.  If they did it legally, good for them, they are one of the favorites in A.  If not, they should garner no sympathy and do it correctly next year.