Jump to content

Pa Hockey

Members
  • Posts

    840
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    42

Posts posted by Pa Hockey

  1. 3 hours ago, Happy Hockey Fan said:

    Now I get it, you are a player from Canevin. I assure you I played there. I can even tell you almost every coach they have had there since 1984. Know many of them personally. Oldaker, Koch, Timmons, Fedor,  Zielmanski, Vacarro, Pawlus, just to name a few. Not allowed to post players names here. 
     

    I guess I shouldn’t argue with you about how many AAA players are on Canevin’s team because you play for them. But kids that played amateur AA this year, but played amateur AAA previously no longer count as AAA players. They are classified as amateur AA players. So I am sure what ever total you claim it to be, it is a lot lower. 3 of your top 10 scorers played AAA this year. 
     

    Lots of really good players on Canevin’s team. Just not as many as most teams that play PIHL AA. 
     

    I wish you nothing but success going forward. Unfortunately we will never get to see you play those teams. Maybe ask your coach to play in the St. Margaret’s pre-season tournament. 
     

    hopefully I will get to see you play next year. I saw you play this year. And you probably were pretty good. 

    Canevin has had a great program for a long time at AA and won over 600 Games and 8 Penguins Cups and 4 State Titles.

    They can play in Non PIHL Tournaments and compete. It would be nice to see them in AA but would mean the players from Seton LaSalle and Keystone Oaks would have to enroll in Canevin and they would be pure. Commitment to the School and Program. Costs money and can be done. People always want o have things both ways and the reality is the the league has rules to follow. 

    Vaccaro played at Ringgold FYI.  

    https://teampages.s3.amazonaws.com/documents/534810/CANEVIN2020F.pdf?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Credential=AKIA3I4H7LHCZ6EPI72U%2F20240404%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20240404T012100Z&X-Amz-Expires=21600&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Signature=33768ac2039199d2518fc9347beb05e66e17dfc9bf1a66915549e6c39336e868

  2. 11 minutes ago, hockeyisgreat said:

    So you are saying that the Schools in D-2 don't work hard?  Those teams and coaches have to work harder to join players from 5 schools together to form a team.  Wow I didn't realize how much you are against D-2.  So that's why you try hard not to recognize their accomplishments!  Very sad!

    I am not against D-2 at all and completely understand the model and appreciate the challenges. They get to play their championship at Lemieux, get coverage on Web, have an all star game and enjoy the same benefits as Varsity AAA, AA and A. Yet you cry discrimination. Stop crying foul and appreciate what d-2 has. Deer Lakes has a JV and will join A Hockey soon and will be another example of the original intention.   

  3. D-2 is impure teams with multiple High Schools and was originally supposed to develop into pure and never did.

    Schools in AAA, AA and A work very hard to earn an opportunity to play for a State Championship and are rewarded for their efforts.  

    TJ beat Greensburg Salem 8-0 in the PAHSS and both had all their players and was a good experience because Salem rebounded and committed themselves and almost pulled off a Penguins Cup this year.

    Canevin sent half their players to play Latrobe ? Why? 

    Look at what Avonworth is doing and South Park is doing with MS and Developmental and they should be applauded  

    • Like 1
  4. 16 minutes ago, Overqualified said:

    Canevin had half there players for that game

    And you hired the worst girl referee I have ever seen for that game it was hilarious 

    Preference why Canevin doesn't play in that tournament anymore 

    You really shouldn't bash teams not good for business 

    If you didn't try to pay 35 dollars to ref a game maybe your tournament would be better 

    Not bashing schools at all they got beat 8-0 and pay refs very well  

  5. 27 minutes ago, Overqualified said:

     

    I wouldn't call losing to top teams by 1 getting outclassed without having some of there best players because they where out of town for the holidays 

    Latrobe beat Canevin 8-0 and Armstrong beat Ringgold 9-2 two years ago 

  6. 20 minutes ago, hockeyisgreat said:

    While that is a wonderful list it is very sad that Keith Barnes does not recognize the co-op players! 

    Ryan Saginaw and Gio Valentine were as good if not better than the Stellar 6!

    It's not their fault that they play for teams that need to combine schools to form a team.  I would say that what they accomplished in some ways was tougher than what the Stellar 6 accomplished!  

    Anyone ever ask Barnes why he doesn't even consider D-2!

    I have been a part of picking the Stellar 6 for almost 30 years and its great that the PG recognizes these players ............do me a favor and congratulate these great kids . D-2 gets plenty of publicity 

  7. 29 minutes ago, stickboy said:

    If you make that call on that play in a state championship, you deserve criticism. Officials in a game of that level should be experienced enough to use discretion. They delivered the ultimate consequence on an act that had no effect on a player or the game. Heck, I’ll willing to bet everyone in attendance was dumbfounded, and if no call was made at all there would have been no real complaint.

    Excellent post 

  8. 11 minutes ago, stickboy said:

    If you make that call on that play in a state championship, you deserve criticism. Officials in a game of that level should be experienced enough to use discretion. They delivered the ultimate consequence on an act that had no effect on a player or the game. Heck, I’ll willing to bet everyone in attendance was dumbfounded, and if no call was made at all there would have been no real complaint.

    Ive done officiating, umpiring and administration  , Bravo for the above post ! 

  9. 11 hours ago, TheRightCall said:

    Excellent points, that is what I was trying to convey. But logic doesnt override sour grapes.

    I have nothing to do with TJ and the soft call ruined a very good hockey game between two very good championship teams. It happened in the past and the officials can do better. TJ was the benefactor of poor officiating in the 2022 Penguins Cup with Franklin, which was a disgraceful display of poor officiating.  

  10. 9 minutes ago, TheRightCall said:

    Just because you know him and he is a "good kid" doesn't preclude him from taking an unwise penalty. Are you implying that this official is not experienced? How do you know? Granted, for a critical call such as this, I would have consulted with my partner for sure; however, if an official sees a penalty, no matter where he or she is on the ice, he or she needs to make the call. Again, you are implying that since he was the back official that he could not effectively make this call, which is not a logical statement at all.

    in

    The point being that this player committed a spearing penalty in a big game; the rules are clear. There is not a different rulebook when playoffs come around; the key is for the officials to effectively communicate with everyone. But again, it was the player who committed the penalty; he only has himself to blame.

    he didn't talk to his fellow officials that were closer to the play (he was  at blue line and backside official) and did not communicate with TJ bench. He went and directly threw the player out of  the game. Watch the Video again and assess how dangerous the intent was.....love tap at best after he was clubbed in the back by the Pennridge player (No Penalty)!

  11. 50 minutes ago, nemesis8679 said:

    Perhaps the kid said or did something in the course of the game that pissed the ref off, so he called something that otherwise wouldn't have been called? 

    I've seen it happen before.

     Pennsylvania High School Hockey Championships Should used seasoned officials who understand the game and control their emotions and make the calls to the best of their ability. What bothers me is that he didn't talk to his fellow officials that were closer to the play (he was  at blue line and backside official) and did not communicate with TJ bench, which normally better officials do. Player is A Captain and top scorer and I know him to be a very good kid. TJ got a bad deal IMO. Read Coach Zeiler's assessment .....it says it all !

    https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/hsother/2024/03/23/high-school-state-hockey-thomas-jefferson-chartiers-valley/stories/202403200158

  12. 19 hours ago, stickboy said:

    If I was a TJ parent/fan/coach/player (which I’m not), I’d be disgruntled about the game misconduct call given to their leading scorer half way through the game.  Refs called it spearing and gave 5 and game for what looked like a love tap after being crosschecked.  Would be interesting to know where the ref is from. 

    Now that I saw video this was a ludicrous call that ruined a great Championship game from a backside official from the blue line .............What a shame  

  13. PENNSYLVANIA CUP - STATE CHAMPIONS   
             
             
    YEAR   STATE AAA CHAMPION STATE AA CHAMPION STATE A CHAMPION
             
    1975    1 BALDWIN (WPIHL) - -
    1976    2 MT LEBANON (WPIHL) ABINGTON (ICSHL) -
    1977    3 CHURCHILL (WPIHL) ERIE FAIRVIEW (LKSHL) -
    1978   - - -
    1979    4 CHURCHILL (WPIHL) SOUTH HILLS CATHOLIC (WPIHL) -
    1980    5 UPPER ST. CLAIR (SHIHL) - -
    1981    6 ARCHBISHOP CARROLL (ICSHL) ERIE FAIRVIEW (LKSHL) -
    1982    7 WEST CHESTER (ICSHL) ERIE FAIRVIEW (LKSHL) -
    1983    8 GERMANTOWN ACADEMY (SHSHL) CANEVIN (SHIHL) -
    1984    9 CATHEDRAL PREP (LKSHL) CANEVIN (SHIHL) -
    1985  10 CONESTOGA (ICSHL) PENNSBURY (LBCSHL) -
    1986  11 CONESTOGA (ICSHL) CHARTIERS VALLEY (SHIHL) -
    1987  12 UPPER ST. CLAIR (SHIHL) MEADVILLE (LKSHL) -
    1988  13 BALDWIN (SHIHL) WILLIAM TENNENT (SHSHL) -
    1989  14 MEADVILLE (LKSHL) CANEVIN (SHIHL) PLUM (WPIHL)
    1990  15 MALVERN PREP (ICSHL) FATHER JUDGE (LBCSHL) BISHOP EGAN (LBCSHL)
    1991  16 COUNCIL ROCK (SHSHL) BEAVER (SHIHL) MONSIGNOR BONNER (EHSHL)
    1992  17 MEADVILLE (LKSHL) COUNCIL ROCK (SHSHL) HAVERFORD (EHSHL)
    1993  18 MEADVILLE (LKSHL) FATHER JUDGE (LBCSHL) GREENSBURG C.C. (WPIHL)
    1994  19 MEADVILLE (LKSHL) GREENSBURG C.C. (WPIHL) BISHOP MCCORT (WPIHL)
    1995  20 MEADVILLE (LKSHL) CONWELL EGAN (LBCSHL) BISHOP MCCORT (WPIHL)
    1996  21 MEADVILLE (LKSHL) GREENSBURG C.C. (WPIHL) BISHOP MCCORT (WPIHL)
    1997  22 BETHEL PARK (SHIHL) CATHEDRAL PREP (LKSHL) BISHOP MCCORT (WPIHL)
    1998  23 LASALLE (ICSHL) THOMAS JEFFERSON (SHIHL) SETON LASALLE (SHIHL)
    1999  24 CONWELL EGAN (LBCSHL) THOMAS JEFFERSON (SHIHL) BISHOP MCCORT (WPIHL)
    2000  25 BETHEL PARK (PIHL) THOMAS JEFFERSON (PIHL) SERRA CATHOLIC (PIHL)
    2001  26 BETHEL PARK (PIHL) BEAVER (PIHL) SERRA CATHOLIC (PIHL)
    2002  27 BETHEL PARK (PIHL) PETERS TWP (PIHL) SERRA CATHOLIC (PIHL)
    2003  28 MEADVILLE (PIHL) PETERS TWP (PIHL) RADNOR (ICSHL)
    2004  29 MALVERN PREP (ICSHL) ARCHBISHOP CARROLL (ICSHL) RADNOR (ICSHL)
    2005  30 BETHEL PARK (PIHL) PETERS TWP (PIHL) PENNCREST (ICSHL)
    2006  31 MT LEBANON (PIHL) PINE RICHLAND (PIHL) QUAKER VALLEY (PIHL)
    2007  32 NORTH ALLEGHENY (PIHL) PINE RICHLAND (PIHL) WEST CHESTER HENDERSON (ICSHL)
    2008  33 LASALLE (ICSHL) LATROBE (PIHL) WEST CHESTER EAST (ICSHL)
    2009  34 LASALLE (ICSHL) LATROBE (PIHL) BAYARD RUSTIN (ICSHL)
    2010  35 CARDINAL O'HARA (EHSHL) LATROBE (PIHL) MARS (PIHL)
    2011  36 UPPER ST. CLAIR (PIHL) CANEVIN (PIHL) MARS (PIHL)
    2012  37 LASALLE (ICSHL) COUNCIL ROCK SOUTH (SHSHL) QUAKER VALLEY (PIHL)
    2013  38 NORTH ALLEGHENY (PIHL) LATROBE (PIHL) WEST CHESTER EAST (ICSHL)
    2014  39 PETERS TWP (PIHL) CENTRAL BUCKS SOUTH (SHSHL) BAYARD RUSTIN (ICSHL)
    2015  40 HOLY GHOST PREP (ICSHL) CATHEDRAL PREP (PIHL) BAYARD RUSTIN (ICSHL)
    2016  41 LASALLE (ICSHL) CENTRAL BUCKS SOUTH (SHSHL) BAYARD RUSTIN (ICSHL)
    2017  42 PETERS TWP (PIHL) DOWNINGTOWN EAST (ICSHL) BAYARD RUSTIN (ICSHL)
    2018  43 ST JOSEPH'S PREP (ICSHL) DOWNINGTOWN EAST (ICSHL) BAYARD RUSTIN (ICSHL)
    2019  44 LASALLE (APAC) PINE RICHLAND (PIHL) BAYARD RUSTIN (ICSHL)
    2020        
    2021  45 MALVERN PREP (APAC) BALDWIN (PIHL) WEST CHESTER EAST (ICSHL)
    2022  46 PETERS TWP (PIHL) PENNRIDGE (SHSHL) WEST CHESTER EAST (ICSHL)
    2023  47 LASALLE (APAC) SOUTH FAYETTE (PIHL) WEST CHESTER EAST (ICSHL)
    2024  48 PINE RICHLAND (PIHL) PENNRIDGE (SHSHL) HERSHEY (CPIHL)
×
×
  • Create New...