Yeah. Even if we take child abuse out of the equation, religion is hogwash to me. I went to catholic school though 8th grade, and I dont' believe any of it. So without going on a tangent, I'll just say that there is no reason that I would send my kid to a school where something none of us believe in is central to the environment.
And that's without even getting into the discussion of a kid missing out on the experience of a regular, diverse, co-ed high school experience.
There's other teams you can play for.